Appeals & Post-Conviction Relief
Criminal Appeals in New York: Your Second Chance at Justice
A guilty verdict doesn’t have to be the end of the road. At Texido Law, we focus on giving people a second chance through the appeals process. Whether your loved one was wrongfully convicted or sentenced unfairly, our firm has the experience and legal skill to fight back.
Nick Texido has personally handled more than 150 felony appeals in New York's appellate courts—including six argued before the state’s highest court. When you need an appellate lawyer who understands the complex rules and deadlines, you need a firm that knows how to win on paper and in the courtroom.
A Trial Isn’t the End—We Help You Fight What Went Wrong
Most appeals come from families who believe the verdict wasn’t right. Maybe evidence was kept out. Maybe a lawyer failed to do their job. Or maybe the judge made a critical error. Whatever the reason, if something went wrong at trial, it can be challenged.
Texido Law handles direct appeals across Buffalo, Western New York, and statewide—providing clear guidance through the appellate process.
New York Criminal Appeals Process
To start an appeal, a Notice of Appeal must be filed within 30 days of sentencing. After that, your attorney compiles the full record from trial—transcripts, motions, and evidence—and prepares detailed legal arguments explaining how your rights were violated. In some cases, oral argument is held before a panel of judges. A decision may take months, but it can result in a conviction being overturned, a new trial ordered, or a sentence being reduced.
Grounds for Appeal in NY
Common reasons for appeal include:
– Legal mistakes by the judge
– Improper jury instructions or misconduct
– Prosecutorial errors
– Ineffective assistance of your original trial attorney
– Lack of evidence supporting the verdict
– Constitutional violations, like unlawful searches or confessions
Texido Law knows how to identify these flaws and build a powerful argument around them.
Why Texido Law for Your Appeal
Nick Texido is one of the few attorneys in Buffalo who focuses deeply on criminal appeals. With over 150 appeals handled, including published decisions and wins in the NY Court of Appeals, he brings a rare level of appellate experience. Appeals aren’t just about knowing the law—they require clear, persuasive writing and the ability to think like a judge. That’s what sets Texido Law apart.
Explore More About the Appeals & Post-Conviction Process
Answers for Families Facing the Appeals Process
How much time do I have to appeal a conviction in NY?
You must file a Notice of Appeal within 30 days after sentencing. Missing this deadline can close the door to your appeal.
Can I present new evidence on appeal?
No—an appeal is based only on what happened in the trial court. If you have new evidence, that may require a separate post-conviction motion (like a CPL 440 motion
What if my loved one pled guilty—can they still appeal?
Sometimes. Appeals from guilty pleas are limited, but certain sentencing issues or constitutional problems may still be challenged. We’ll help evaluate the options.
What are the chances of winning an appeal?
It depends on the facts, but many appeals succeed in modifying sentences or securing new trials. We’ll give you an honest, experienced opinion on your chances.
How long does a criminal appeal take in New York?
Most appeals take several months to over a year, depending on the court backlog and complexity of the case.