Being arrested is overwhelming. Whether it happens in Buffalo, Cheektowaga, Tonawanda, Amherst, Niagara Falls, or anywhere across Western New York, what you do in the hours and days after an arrest can significantly impact your case.
As an experienced criminal lawyer in Western New York, Texido Law has seen many cases where the outcome could have been improved if the individual knew what mistakes to avoid. Protecting your rights starts with understanding what not to do.
Below are the top 7 mistakes people make after an arrest in WNY — and how to avoid them.
1. Talking to Police Without a Lawyer Present
One of the most damaging mistakes is speaking to police officers after an arrest.
Many people believe that cooperating or explaining “their side” will help them. In reality, law enforcement is trained to gather statements that can later be used against you.
Anything you say can be misinterpreted, taken out of context, or used to build a stronger case against you.
The fix:
Politely assert your right to remain silent and request to speak with a criminal attorney WNY
as soon as possible.
2. Posting About the Arrest on Social Media
Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat posts are often pulled as evidence in criminal cases. Even “private” accounts are not fully safe — screenshots and digital trails can still be obtained.
Discussing your case publicly can harm your credibility and restrict your defense options.
The fix:
Avoid sharing anything about your arrest, charges, or the incident online until your case is fully resolved.
3. Contacting the Alleged Victim or Witnesses
People often attempt to “clear things up” by reaching out to others involved in the incident. This is extremely risky.
Contacting someone could:
-
Lead to new charges in Buffalo or anywhere in WNY
-
Violate a protective order
-
Be perceived as intimidation or witness tampering
The fix:
Do not reach out to anyone connected to the case. Let your criminal lawyer in Western New York handle communication through proper legal channels.
4. Missing Court Dates or Ignoring Court Instructions
If you are charged in Buffalo City Court, Erie County Court, Niagara County Court, or any local town or village court, missing a court date can result in:
-
A bench warrant
-
Additional criminal charges
-
Higher bail
-
Loss of credibility in front of the judge
The fix:
Track all court dates carefully. Set reminders and speak with your attorney immediately if something affects your ability to appear.
5. Assuming the Charges Will “Go Away”
Many people hope that if they stay quiet and keep a low profile, the charges will eventually be dismissed. That is almost never the case. Prosecutors in Western New York aggressively pursue criminal charges, including:
-
DWI and DUI
-
Assault
-
Drug possession
-
Domestic violence
-
Weapon charges
-
Theft and property crimes
-
Felonies and violent offenses
Waiting too long to hire an attorney can make your situation far worse.
The fix:
Speak to a criminal attorney in WNY as soon as possible to protect your rights and start preparing a defense.
6. Not Understanding the Consequences of a Criminal Record
A conviction in New York — even for a misdemeanor — can affect:
-
Employment
-
Housing
-
Immigration status
-
Professional licenses
-
Your ability to own or possess a firearm
Many residents in Buffalo, Amherst, West Seneca, Lockport, and throughout Western New York underestimate how far-reaching these consequences can be.
The fix:
Discuss the long-term impact with your lawyer. In some cases, you may qualify for record sealing or alternative programs.
7. Choosing the Wrong Criminal Defense Lawyer
Not all attorneys are equipped to handle complex criminal cases. You need a lawyer with:
-
Experience in Western New York courts
-
Knowledge of local judges and prosecutors
-
A strong record of trial and appellate success
-
Background in serious felonies, DWIs, and violent crimes
Your freedom and future depend on choosing the right representation.
The fix:
Hire a criminal lawyer Western New York
who understands the local court system and has a proven defense background.
Protect Your Rights After an Arrest in Western New York
An arrest does not define your future — but your decisions afterward can. With the right legal guidance, you can avoid costly mistakes and take control of your case.
Texido Law represents clients in:
-
Buffalo
-
Erie County
-
Niagara County
-
Chautauqua County
-
Cattaraugus County
-
All Western New York courts
If you or someone you love has been arrested, the most important step is contacting an experienced criminal attorney WNY immediately.
Texido Law can help you understand your rights, avoid missteps, and build the strongest defense possible.
